It's Timmy's (Tara Strong) first Fairy-Versary and Cosmo (Daran Norris) and Wanda (Susan Blakeskee) give Timmy a rule-free wish muffin which means whoever eats the muffin gets a wish that does not apply by the rules. But Mr. Crocker (Carlos Alazraqui) is still on the lookout for the fairies and showing them to the world.