Harrison encounters 'God' (Ann-Margret) in a hospital storage room who knows personal things about him, whom he later tries to hook a meeting up with Brooke. Carmen attends a meeting for teens of alcoholic parents seemingly sharing something in common with Nicole her greatest rival. Meanwhile, the school puts on the play Equus, which has hilarious results between Josh and Lily. Sam dives into her role in the play as the shrink trying to help Lily and Josh through self-esteem issues.